IELTS 文章首页
考点与干扰项剖析 · 同义替换精讲

包含与排除的替换:include、as well as、except for的考场识别

翻开雅思听力真题,你会发现一个奇怪的规律:考“包含”的时候,录音里几乎不出现 include;考“排除”的时候,except for 也不常以原词现身。 以剑 7 Test4 Section 3 的 Q2…

Kapi 雅思 约 6 分钟阅读 4 个真题引用

翻开雅思听力真题,你会发现一个奇怪的规律:考“包含”的时候,录音里几乎不出现 include;考“排除”的时候,except for 也不常以原词现身。

以剑 7 Test4 Section 3 的 Q23-Q26 正确选项:A题目上下文:这组匹配题包含 Q23 Geographical Location、Q24 Economy、Q25 Overview of Education System、Q26 Role of English Language,需要从 A-C 选项中配对;其中 Q23 的项目是「Geographical Location」;A:They will definitely include this topic. 为例。

四道匹配题共享一套选项——A. definitely include / B. might include / C. will not include——考的就是两个学生在地理演示中“放哪些主题、不放哪些主题”的决策过程。题目选项里满是 include,但录音中这两个学生从头到尾没说过一次 include 这个单词。

决策三态的听辨:确认、拖延、转移

剑 7 Test4 Section 3 的匹配题把“包含/排除/待定”三种状态压缩在同一道大题里,形成了天然的对比实验。

先说 definitely include 是怎么被说出来的。Q23 正确选项:A题目上下文:这是一道匹配题,项目是「Geographical Location」;A:They will definitely include this topic. 对应的录音中,一方提出:“do you think we ought to say something about the geographical location”,另一方回应:“Yes, okay. I'll take notes.” 对话里没有 include,但“ought to say something about…”加上“Okay, I'll take notes”这套组合——提议 + 接受 + 记录动作——已经完成了“确定包含”的语义。

Q25 正确选项:A题目上下文:这是一道匹配题,项目是「Overview of Education System」;A:They will definitely include this topic. 同理,“Okay, so general overview of education”的复述也是确认信号。

再说 might include。Q24 正确选项:B题目上下文:这是一道匹配题,项目是「Economy」;B:They might include this topic. 讨论经济话题时,一方认为很重要,另一方却说:“let's think about that one later, shall we? Let's see how we're doing for time.” “later”和“see how we're doing for time”把决定推迟了——既没否定也没确认,对应“可能包含”。

最值得警惕的是 will not include。Q26 正确选项:C题目上下文:这是一道匹配题,项目是「Role of English Language」;C:They will not include this topic 提到“the role of English language”之后,立刻被否定:“No, that goes in the language policy seminar. don't you remember?”——“Are you sure?”——“Positive.” 录音没有说“我们不包含这个主题”,而是说“这个内容归到另一个研讨会里”。

一段归类转移,就完成了排除。

三个选项分别对应三种信号词群:确认词(Okay / I'll take notes)、拖延词(later / see how)、归类转移词(that goes in…)。考场上你不需要听到 include,需要的是对决策动作本身的识别速度。

except for 的两个替身

机经 3 Test4 Section 3 Q21 答案:classical history题目上下文:这是一道填空题,空格所在题干是「Can be combined with any other subject except ____」 的题目这样写:“Can be combined with any other subject except ______.” 录音里学生问能否搭配人类学,老师回答:“you can combine it with any other subject apart from classical history.” apart from 直接对应题干里的 except,答案 classical history 跟在后面。

不少考生在这道题上栽跟头,原因是听到“anthropology”就先落笔了——但那是可以搭配的科目,真正的例外在后面。

排除逻辑在选择题里识别起来更难一层。剑 8 Test2 Section 4 Q32 正确选项:B题目上下文:这是一道选择题,题干问「What types of people were included in the research?」;B:men who were working 问:“What types of people were included in the research?” 选项给了年轻人第一份工作、在职男性、失业女性三个方向。

录音中研究者说:18岁以下排除,只聚焦在有工作的男性。excluded 过滤掉一批人,focus on 锁定另一批人——“在职男性”才是纳入对象。选项里的“失业女性”和“年轻人”都在录音中被明确排除或另作他用。这一题的考点不是单词替换,而是范围筛选:你能否用录音里的“谁不入选”来推“谁入选”。

as well as:并列不是背景音

剑 15 Test4 Section 4 Q32 答案:technology题目上下文:这是一道填空题,空格所在题干是「Developments in production of goods and in ____ greatly changed lives.」 是一道 Section 4 笔记填空题。

题干写的是:“Developments in production of goods and in ______ greatly changed lives.” 录音原话是:“improvements in how goods were made, as well as in technology, triggered massive social changes.” 改写链条很清楚:improvementsDevelopmentsas well asand,空格对应 technology

as well as 在这里的作用是连接两个并列项——商品生产方式和技术。题干把 as well as 改写成了 and,但如果你在听录音时把 as well as 当背景连接词、注意力只停留在前半句,很容易漏掉后半。并列结构的考点恰恰在于:出题人往往把答案放在 as well as后面,而不是前面。

考场信号词速查

把上面几个案例浓缩成一组考场可用的信号词群,比背十个同义替换表更管用:

包含信号:as well as / also / in addition to / no extra charge / part of the package / focus on / ought to + 确认回应(Okay / Yes)

排除信号:apart from / except / but not / rather than / instead of / exclude / that goes in…(归类转移)

待定信号:later / see how we're doing for time / might / maybe

在真实考试中,听到提议时等着听回应,听到并列时警惕后半段,听到肯定回答后等一等可能跟过来的限制条件——这三个习惯,才是识别包含与排除替换的真正核心。